Rachel Perkins has loved Billy Jenkins for as long as she can remember. But one terrible mistake has shattered her world, leaving her heartbroken and questioning whether love - no matter how deep - can ever be restored.

Billy is somewhat of a legend in their small school. His dark wavy hair, brown eyes and dimples could make any girl's heart flutter. Every boy in school wants to be him and every girl wants to date him. Rachel, on the other hand, is quiet and reserved, always obedient. Labeled as an outcast and bullied by her peers, she longs for Billy to notice her again. When Rachel is reluctantly dragged to a party, she and Billy unexpectedly reconnect. For a brief moment, it feels like old times - until Billy crosses a line, leaving Rachel shattered and questioning everything she thought she knew about him. Billy, consumed by guilt and regret, turns to his older brother for advice and, seeking redemption, surrenders his heart to God. Now, he's determined to prove he's changed and make things right with Rachel. He's willing to fight for her forgiveness and win her trust. But Rachel is angry, hurt, and torn between her past love for Billy and the heartbreak he caused. But when she's faced with a life-altering truth that ties her to Billy forever, the past becomes impossible to ignore.

Can Rachel forgive Billy for his betrayal? Can Billy forgive himself? Can they overcome past hurts and find love again?