A desperate teacher, a practical woman, and one accidentally-sent email create the most complicated fake relationship in Prince Edward Island Amish country.

The matchmaking mothers of New Hope have big plans for their new male schoolteacher, but Michael Beller just wants to focus on teaching. His impulsive solution: invite Anna Roth to his brother's wedding as a pretend companion. Anna, who's been working with Michael to translate century-old journals, sees the invitation as a chance to step outside her quiet, orderly life.

What starts as a practical arrangement quickly becomes complicated. Michael finds himself genuinely drawn to Anna's quick wit and gentle spirit, while Anna discovers there's more to life than dusty documents and museum work. With the whole community watching and meddlesome teenager Samy Yoder stirring up trouble, their fake relationship threatens to become embarrassingly real.

When the wedding visit ends, will Michael and Anna return to their separate lives, or will they find the courage to make their pretend romance genuine?