The Amish community in Little Valley is facing big changes, and big threats, with tourism booming. It becomes clear that some of the new businesses want control of the market, and it looks like they are willing to go to great lengths to get it.

With one barn after another set on fire in the middle of the night, it becomes personal, and the community is scared for the well-being of their families and their future in Little Valley.

Anna and Beth are considered the wise women in the community and are equipped with a few solved murder mysteries under their belt. The sisters are ready once again to untangle the clues and find the real story behind the fires. Will they be able to solve the mystery and convince the community to stay?