The waters are rising in New Eden. A record-breaking flood pushes the community to its limits, testing their faith and their bonds of friendship. In the muddy wake of the storm, a discovery is made: a hidden box containing the diary of a young Amish woman from over a century ago. As Sarah and Daniel read her words, a tale of forbidden love and a violent, long-buried injustice comes to light, revealing that the very foundation of their community is not what it seems.

Nature's fury is nothing compared to the secrets of men.