When four-year-old Amanda gets off the train, looking for a more suitable restroom, the train leaves with her sister on it. She reports to the town sheriff and complicates the man's bachelor life. All the young ladies in town would be willing to help him take charge of the stranded miss, but he chooses the one woman who has never tried to cast a net over him. She never has because she is flustered every time they cross paths. Now why would that be so?