Piper McCall is a renowned artist and, when she's asked to donate one of her sculptures for a local charity event, she ends up giving far more than she intended to when her sister accidentally delivers the wrong sculpture to the auction. Realizing her priceless sculpture has been sold, she's determined to get it back, but the buyer turns out to be a rival from her past that she continues to harbor unresolved feelings for. Can Piper persuade him to return what she never intended to sell? Or does the Lord have other plans for her and the man she's sure she doesn't want to be the love of her life?