In the charming little town of Heartsboro- rumored to be the birthplace of Cupid- Valentine's Day is more than candy hearts and roses; it's a tradition. Every year, the Valentine's Ball draws hopeful singles to its twinkling dance floor, all chasing the promise of true love. The town buzzes with excitement as whispers of Cupid's annual appearance ignite imaginations and stir hearts.

But Liz Blackstone isn't buying it.

Back in Heartsboro for her twentieth high school homecoming, Liz has no patience for childhood myths or whimsical beliefs. Her former high school boyfriend feels the same. With old wounds and a shared skepticism, they find themselves laughing at the town's continued obsession with love-struck arrows and Cupid's magic. It's just a relic of a romantic past. Right?