Eleanore Gingrich loves teaching the scholars in her Old Order Mennonite Community but really hopes for a home and family of her own. She has been struggling to accept and manage chronic health problems when mysterious gifts begin showing up at school and at home. Could the man she is secretly interested in be sending them or is someone playing a trick on her?

Joshua Weaver had to put his life on hold to raise his younger sister after their parents died. Now, he is not sure how to pursue a life of his own, especially when all his efforts to get to know one particular woman have been thwarted. He continuously dodges the women his well-meaning but meddling sister tries to set him up with while figuring out who has left him a surprise gift.

Will Eleanore and Josh be able to discover the identity of the mysterious gift giver, and can they overcome the obstacles that have kept them from finding happiness?