Marie Koeppler left the Mennonite community in search of a new life, but twenty-three years later, providence has brought her home. Returning to Sommerfeld with her daughter, Beth, Marie finds that the shadows of the past are longer than she imagined.

When suspicious thefts turn the town against them, Marie’s only hope might be Henry Braun—the man whose heart she once held. Henry is certain he's moved on, yet Marie’s presence stirs a longing he can’t ignore. In a town where reputation is everything, they must decide if their rekindled love is strong enough to survive the accusations threatening to tear them apart.