One snowy Christmas Eve, Jayla and her sister, Honey, make a big batch of Reindeer Nibbles (Ribbles) and bake animal biscuits. The sisters, along with their father, visit Sweet Olive Farm Animal Rescue to deliver treats for the animals. After arriving at the Farm, Jayla finds herself involved in a new adventure. Her curiosity gets the best of her as she tries to solve a mystery leading down the path to a “long-lost” reindeer. Trouble finds her—and so does the reindeer. Feeling the need to help her new friend, mishaps begin. Jayla and the reindeer are both fun-loving spirits who sometimes become mischievous trouble-makers. After they meet, the new friends spend Christmas Eve going from one calamity to the next. By the end of the night, the two learn that their unique ability to create mishaps is, in fact, a delightful quality. They learn to embrace life and all its mishaps.