Rachel Held Evans Asks What is Biblical Womanhood?

Posted by Sam Hailes  ·  5 visitor comments

Rachel Held Evans grew up in the Bible Belt. Raised as a conservative evangelical in Dayton Tennessee, the now author and prominent blogger wasn’t supposed to question her faith. But she did.

It began with the topic of hell. Rachel was reading The Diary of Anne Frank at school. One day she raised her hand and asked, “Did Anne Frank go to hell?”

“This of course made the teacher a little uncomfortable! I had that sceptical quizzical mind, and a really tender heart, which I got from my mother. So when something didn’t line up with what felt right, just and good I wondered if it was of God.”

Rachel explains that in a fundamentalist worldview, if you doubt one doctrine, the entire picture quickly crumbles.

“For a while I wondered if this required throwing out my faith entirely but thankfully I worked through that to a point where I’ve realised questions and doubts and evolving in your faith and changing your mind is just a part of the process of following Christ.

Rachel’s hometown is best known for the Scopes trial where John T Scopes was prosecuted for teaching evolution in public schools back in the 1930s. It wasn’t the easiest of contexts to doubt young earth creationism, but Rachel has nothing but love for her friends and family there.

“They were great people, wonderful people. The first to show up with a casserole when you get sick. But it was a difficult place to struggle with questions about faith just because you don’t doubt your faith in the Bible Belt. But I did so that proved to be interesting and challenging.”

But what of Rachel’s views on hell today? Her answer has clear similarities with Rob Bell’s – another prominent evangelical to question traditional views.

“I’m still struggling through that. As if anyone of us could know for sure what happens after death and what that looks like, so I’m struggling through it with the assumption that that’s not something I’m ever going to know for sure anyway and I find it a bit arrogant that people think they could know for sure.”

A Year of Biblical Womanhood

Another issue that Rachel has wrestled with is the topic of women in the church. Her latest book 'A Year of Biblical Womanhood' is the result of a year-long commitment to following the Bible’s instructions to women as literally as possible.

“I had to cover my head every time I prayed thanks to the Apostle Paul, I had to grow out my hair. I had to observe Biblical purity laws and hone my domestic skills. I turned Proverbs 31 into a to do list which I don’t recommend. It’s a terrible idea!”

There’s plenty of funny stories throughout the book as Rachel practices everything from cooking to silence, all the while making the point that everyone is selective in which sections of the Bible’s instructions to women that they follow.

“I focused on a different virtue each month so I could have some focus and so I wouldn’t have to do some of this stuff all year long like the levitical purity laws. That was nuts! One month I focused on silence and I wanted to look at the downside of silence and how the Bible has been used to silence women through the years. I also wanted to focus on the upside of silence and why contemplative prayer and stillness and quietness might be a good thing.”

“I spent a couple of days in a Benedictine monastery in Alabama. I’m an introvert so it was like Disneyland. It was wonderful and I learned a lot from nurturing that contemplative spirit and prayer and quietness. I observed all the Jewish holidays which was really really fun. I had some help with an orthodox Jewish lady from Israel. We had a Passover Seder which requires you to drink four glasses of wine so a fun time was had by all!”

'Too Bad You're A Girl!'

The hot topic of women leadership has had implications for Rachel from an early age.

“I gave a little talk and did a pretty decent job of my testimony. I sat down afterwards and a guy said ‘Rachel you’re such a great speaker it’s too bad you’re a girl’. He knew that meant I couldn’t do anything with those gifts in the church.”

“I keep meeting woman after woman who is in the exact same spot but hasn’t been able to articulate why she feels left out when she keeps being told ‘you’re equal you just can’t do this or that’. ‘Equal but…’ is always a problem. I got a message the other day from a woman who said for the first time she felt free to be able to speak at her Bible study. Being a part of that is so rewarding. I really feel like I’ve found a voice in this conversation and I’m helping other women find their voice so that’s what keeps me writing.”

Frustrated with teaching that tells women they can't be pastors but should stay at home and pursue motherhood, Rachel questions the phrase ‘Biblical Womanhood’.

“Anytime we try to pin down biblical womanhood a woman from scripture comes along and is praised for doing the complete opposite. So Jael did not exactly exhibit a quiet and gentle spirit when she drove a tent peg through Sisera’s skull, yet she is praised for doing so!”

Challenging Perceptions

Is Rachel arguing that the Bible is never prescriptive on this topic? “We have to filter scripture through the lens of Jesus Christ,” she replies.

“What I don’t see is prescription on how to uniquely follow Christ as a woman. That’s where we disagree with a lot of folks in the States, this idea that being a woman somehow changes what you can and can’t do as a follower of Christ. We have to read the letters of Paul in context. He wasn’t writing the epistles to make new laws he was just talking about how to apply Christ’s teaching in those unique contexts.”

Rachel says she wants to “challenge” people’s notions of Biblical womanhood.

"By taking things hyper-literally I was trying to show none of us are practicing biblical womanhood and none of us want to practice biblical womanhood because there are some very troubling stories in scripture about what womanhood meant in a highly patriarchal society. I’m hoping this [book] will take out of the conversation this bludgeon of ‘I don’t allow women to teach in my church because of biblical womanhood.’ Well, no you don’t! Because the women aren’t covering their heads!”

“I’m also hoping it will be entertaining, funny and interesting to people,” she adds.

It’s difficult to find anything Rachel has written that doesn’t fall into at least one of those categories. Her blog regularly nails all three adjectives. Whether or not you agree with her theology, her style has won the author support from across the denominational spectrum, and rightly so. Utilizing humour in the best possible way, Rachel continues to use her writing gift to impress, challenge and reassure her reader. 

8th October

October 8th, 2012 - Posted & Written by Sam Hailes

Thumbs Down0
Thumbs Up0

Did you find this article useful?

5 Visitor Comments

Join in the Eden community and comment on this article

Fiona

Fiona

Posts: 1

Thanks very much for this interview, Sam. My first thought when I saw the blurb was - oh no, another book telling me what a Christian woman is supposed to look like. But I'm presently surprised. Thank you. I think I'll be putting this in my letter to Santa this year.

Monday, 8th October 2012 at 1:16PM

Reply to this comment

0Thumbs Down
0Thumbs Up

Did you find this comment useful?

Simon

Simon

Posts: 1

I think the same could be said of biblical masculinity (the eldest of Israel slept with his step-mum, his two brothers committed genocide, and the other seven sold their younger brother into the slave trade). I not sure the problem is a gender issue but how we interpret scripture.

Tuesday, 9th October 2012 at 4:59PM

Reply to this comment

0Thumbs Down
0Thumbs Up

Did you find this comment useful?

Mari Howard

Mari Howard

Posts: 4

:-) I see Fiona 'believes in' Santa? Seriuolsy, found this article very interesting, as a non-Bible belt woma,n , as it demonstrates the struggles of those who are. I knew lots of them when we lived in grad student appartments - many who struggled to financially put their hubby through college - hum, a woman can supporther man, but not be a preacher/pastor?

Tuesday, 9th October 2012 at 8:49PM

Reply to this comment

0Thumbs Down
0Thumbs Up

Did you find this comment useful?

royalpriestess

royalpriestess

Posts: 4

As if anyone of us could know for sure what happens after death... Eh? Luke 16:22-28?? Jesus seemed pretty sure, was He being arrogant??? This creation of grey areas around topics that the Word is black and white about is the reason I no longer read this woman's blog - she has the same attitude towards homosexuality/lesbianism. Test the spirit.

Friday, 19th October 2012 at 12:50AM

Reply to this comment

0Thumbs Down
0Thumbs Up

Did you find this comment useful?

J C E JAMES

J C E JAMES

Posts: 1

I've just been offered your book as an 'extra' (specially reduced price) after my order was processed, and accepted the challenge, so I shall be reading the book soon.

Saturday, 14th September 2013 at 7:50PM

Reply to this comment

0Thumbs Down
0Thumbs Up

Did you find this comment useful?

Leave A Comment

Leave your comments or suggestions in regards to this article.

Product Spotlight
A Year Of Biblical Womanhood

A Year Of Biblical Womanhood

Availability: Stock available.

Offer Price: £9.11

Most Popular Articles
Advent Reflection: 11th December - Ian Shaw
Posted on Sunday 11th of December
Advent Reflection: 10th December - Richard Harries
Posted on Saturday 10th of December
Advent Reflection 9th December - Amy Boucher Pye
Posted on Friday 9th of December
Advent Reflection: 8th December - Kel Richards
Posted on Thursday 8th of December
Advent Reflection: 7th December - Davis Bunn
Posted on Wednesday 7th of December
Advent Reflection: 11th December - Ian Shaw
Posted on Sunday 11th of December
Advent Reflection: 10th December - Richard Harries
Posted on Saturday 10th of December
Advent Reflection 9th December - Amy Boucher Pye
Posted on Friday 9th of December
Advent Reflection: 8th December - Kel Richards
Posted on Thursday 8th of December
Advent Reflection: 7th December - Davis Bunn
Posted on Wednesday 7th of December
What Are Eden Bundles?
Posted on Friday 11th of November
Creating an all age, fun, and messy church
Posted on Wednesday 28th of March

Updates from the live @Edencouk twitter feed!

Twitter Seperator
Don't forget to follow us @edencouk
Recent Article Comments
No Comments.

Nia Wright has made 0 posts.

34 useful comments

A Reader has made 0 posts.

16 useful comments

Les Ellison has made 54 posts.

10 useful comments

Ian Matthews has made 8 posts.

8 useful comments

Lyn Myers has made 5 posts.

8 useful comments

Last updated: 24 mins ago